Main Menu

David's Deliberations

Passover Haggadahs

Passover brings to Politics and Prose a rich set of Haggadahs (Haggadot in Hebrew) on display in the front of the store. I am so pleased that Carla Cohen's bibliography, began many years ago, continues to be used and appropriately revised. Carla started the bibliography to assist families in choosing a Haggadah that would fit their Seder needs for family and friends.

In response to a New York Times article on new Haggadahs, a few days ago, a friend asked, “What's wrong with the traditional ones?” Haggadah means narrative or telling. Narratives change. As the essentials of the Exodus story are retold, different emphases are placed on the story.

The newer haggadahs certainly make use of tradition, but they adapt it to contemporary situations so that we increase our ability to experience the Exodus ourselves. And we do this by asking ourselves questions: What are we enslaved to? What forms of slavery continue to exist in our country? In other countries? What can we do about it? What plagues afflict us now? What can we learn from those who fought for freedom and resisted slavery. In our own Seder, Sojourner Truth, Rosa Parks, Nelson Mandela, Desmond Tutu, Martin Luther King, Hannah Senesh, Frederic Douglass, Chaika Grossman, and countless others have had active parts. 

$29.99
ISBN-13: 9780316069861
Availability: On Our Shelves Now
Published: Little, Brown and Company, 2/2012

Many years there are new Haggadahs. This year New American Haggadah (Little, Brown, $29.99) is a star. In addition to its beautiful illustrations, it contains rich commentary and wonderful collection of songs. This Haggadah will stimulate ongoing discussions and lift people spirits with its music. Carla would have loved it, and she also would have appreciated the personal connections with the contributors. Jonathan Safran Foer, grew up buying and browsing books at P&P (as did his author brothers Franklin and Joshua), Jeffrey Goldberg who wrote the Haggadah's Nation commentaries has visited P&P for his books and to help welcome other authors. Translator Nathan Englander and Rebecca Newberger Goldstein have each presented at P&P. 

A few older books are my favorites. They add to the quality of discussion. They are not the only good books, but I have turned to them frequently


$22.95
ISBN-13: 9780805242423
Availability: On Our Shelves Now
Published: Schocken, 2/2007

Marge Piercy's Pesach for the Rest of Us (Schocken, $22.95) puts matters into historical perspective so that the Seder speaks powerfully to your own circle, particularly to that of secular and non-fundamentalist, religious Jews.


$24.99
ISBN-13: 9781580231848
Availability: Not currently in the store – Usually ships in 1-5 days
Published: Jewish Lights Publishing, 2/2004
  David Arnow's Creating Lively Passover Seders (Jewish Lights, $24.99) takes us past dry ritual and order. Lively discussions make a Seder memorable. Arnow has suggestions to stimulate such discussion. 

$19.99
ISBN-13: 9780062018106
Availability: On Our Shelves Now
Published: Harper, 3/2011

 

Cokie and Steve Roberts' Our Haggadah: Uniting Traditions for Interfaith Families (HarperCollins, $19.99) fits for the increasing number of interfaith families who celebrate Passover. Even culturally Jewish families often have not had the education or experience to feel knowledgeable about conducting a Seder, and this book provides an informed and comfortable start. Our Haggadah has added value for non-Jewish participants who wish to engage in the Seder.

$16.00
ISBN-13: 9780060675530
Availability: Not currently in the store – Usually ships in 1-5 days
Published: HarperOne, 2/1995

 

Irwin Steingroot's Keeping Passover (HarperOne, $16) is a marvelous guide to the Seder's rituals and meanings behind each step. It's superb both for Seder preparation and for a participant to weave in a few points of learning during the Seder.


I’d love to recommend the following two Haggadahs, but they are out-of-print or unavailable at this time. Perhaps you can borrow one from a friend or find them through a used book dealer.

Rabbi Richard Levy's On Wings of Freedom was a breakthrough Haggadah when it appeared in 1989. Its translations reflect an egalitarian and non-sexist mindset, filled with ancient and modern readings including lots from the Song of Songs. It connects contemporary events with personal spiritual concerns.

Jonathan Sachs' The Chief Rabbi's Haggadah has elegant essays to accompany a traditional Haggadah. Rabbi Sachs, an Orthodox Jew, provides a learned and humane approach to the Passover story. He is the Chief Rabbi of the United Kingdom and has stood down intolerance within the British Jewish community. His midrash (interpretation) of how Moses was conceived is alone worth reading the book. That is but a foretaste of matters to be read in Sachs' writing.

  Click here for more of our suggested Haggadahs.

We interpret Next Year in Jerusalem (the traditional Seder closing before the songs) to mean Next Year in a City of Peace. May All Humanity Be Redeemed. 

-       David Cohen